Wednesday evening our studio attended an interesting event organized by The Sir John Soane Museum, The Landmark Trust and the LSE Cities Programme. The event was titled: Broken Edges: Cities and Other Ruins – an exhibition at Soane’s, followed by a lecture and discussion at LSE. The centre piece of the event was Astley Castle, this year’s RIBA Stirling Prize Winner, an inspired restoration and development of a ruin by the Architects Witherford Watson Mann on behalf of Landmark Trust. This event well rounded our recent thoughts on the poetics of work-in-progress, especially that of the construction process.
The beauty of a ruin, like that of a building site, resides in our ability to see into the temporary state of a building. The time unfolds in front of us, opening up layers of time previously hidden in a way which often inspires the end result…
Sometimes, the state of the temporary lasts in continuum. Cities are just such an example, where making and re-making of the physicality around us makes up for a vibrant city.
At other times and on a smaller scale, this state is short lived, or at least most visible over shorter period of time. This is the case with building sites. Our projects-in-progress, one in London and another in Dorset, sometimes inspire a wish to suspend the moment of progress. A wish to retain the ruin. but also to complete it…
![](http://static.guim.co.uk/sys-images/Travel/Pix/pictures/2012/8/9/1344512369565/Astley-Castle-dining-room-008.jpg) |
Restoration of Astley Castle in Warwickshire by Witherford Watson Mann architects.
(source: theguardian.com) |
![](http://c1038.r38.cf3.rackcdn.com/group5/building45276/media/rybj_astleycastle_08.jpg) |
Broken edge between the old and the new at Astley Castle.
(source: openbuildings.com) |
![](http://2.bp.blogspot.com/-XlIdxB-b7E8/Uvzd-55on3I/AAAAAAAAAzw/Y4YO7U8jM5g/s1600/2014-02-10+11.28.33.jpg) |
Old Fireplace at Ebenezer Cottage in Dorset. |
![](http://4.bp.blogspot.com/-vc30W5X9TVc/UvzeWaiXxhI/AAAAAAAAAz4/XFIV8WUiwKY/s1600/2014-01-21+13.19.01.jpg) |
Work-in-progress at Ebenezer Cottage. |
![](http://4.bp.blogspot.com/-vcatXbbWsA8/Uv0GRT__NbI/AAAAAAAAA0M/ch0kgvACqIw/s1600/2013-11-22+13.48.14.jpg) |
Old masonry walls at Ebenezer Cottage. |
![](http://4.bp.blogspot.com/-9vlS0g200vA/Uv0Gbwgmv3I/AAAAAAAAA0Q/7CSoFwTGReM/s1600/IMG_4503.JPG) |
Old and new timbers at Elizabeth Mews in London. |
![](http://4.bp.blogspot.com/-r-HSCuyyihs/Uv0Glx5QzTI/AAAAAAAAA0Y/KxzyNp4vYJo/s1600/IMG_4677.JPG) |
Old brickwork arch and ceiling timbers at Elizabeth Mews. |